5.3 Enforcement and Management

Help reduce congestion and improve travel times on local and arterial roads and highways by consistent enforcement of road facility use and effective incident detection.

Description

Enforcement and management programs provide a variety of tools that, alone or in combination with other measures such as traffic operations and signalization improvements, can provide additional means to improve traffic flow conditions, both locally and at the corridor-wide level.

Many traffic flow improvements involve some modifications of driving behavior by local residents and commuters. As a result, the programs most likely to be successful are those providing the greatest incentives or disincentives to change. Strict enforcement of traffic flow improvements such as restricted left turns and parking limitations, for example, discourages violations. If initial enforcement of the programs is pursued vigorously, it can eventually be relaxed somewhat. Overly restrictive measures should be avoided. Very high fines, for instance, may be unacceptable to most users, fostering general resentment toward the program.

Enforcement and management strategies typically involve a substantial amount of time and planning to implement when compared to signalization or operations improvement programs.

Management measures can implement on-street parking and may involve establishing new no-stopping zones at select locations for the peak period or all day; relocation and consolidation of cab stands, tour bus stops, loading zones, and handicapped parking spaces; and removal of short-term parking meters.

Incident detection programs can significantly reduce the average duration of lane blockages. Roving tow or service vehicles can respond rapidly to traffic blockages. Using a surveillance and management system can increase the percentages of highway sections that are relatively free flowing versus those that are congested. Broad application of ramp metering can significantly benefit regional mobility by increasing average highway speeds, decreasing travel times, and reducing congestion on the corridor.

Enforcement activities feature a highly visible program that includes meter readers, motorcycle police officers, and tow trucks. For example, an intense enforcement policy would reduce the number of illegal long-term parking at metered spaces, increasing curb-side parking capacity, and would also reduce incidences of double parking, improving arterial capacity and decreasing travel times.

Enforcement and management activities impose capital, operating, and maintenance costs. For example, an enforcement program at a specific facility includes the labor costs associated with traffic control officers providing patrols and surveillance of the facility during its operation. Traffic and parking enforcement programs require meter readers, uniformed police officers, and tow trucks. However, the revenue generated by fines usually exceeds costs by a factor of seven or more.

An incident management system entails costs for embedded traffic detectors, changeable message signs, closed-circuit televisions, and central computer control. Metered ramps require additional signals and signage.

Application

Controlled access highways and arterials.

Incident Management

Daily Emission Reduction (grams/day)=E𝑅𝐸𝐺×Fπ‘π‘…Γ—βˆ‘i=1nF𝐸𝑓𝑓iΓ—(𝐴𝐷𝑇i𝐴𝐷𝑇T)\text{Daily Emission Reduction (grams/day)} = E_{\mathit{REG}} \times F_{\mathit{NR}} \times \sum_{i=1}^{n} F_{\mathit{Eff}\ i} \times \left( \frac{\mathit{ADT}_{i}}{\mathit{ADT}_{T}} \right)

The amount of regional nonrecurring congestion emissions multiplied by the sum of each link’s effectiveness and proportion to the total regional average daily traffic (ADT)

Variables (Unit) Definitions
𝐴𝐷𝑇i\mathit{ADT}_{i} Average daily traffic for each affected link
𝐴𝐷𝑇T\mathit{ADT}_{T} (vehicles/day) Total average daily traffic for affected system
E𝑅𝐸𝐺E_{\mathit{REG}} (gram) Regional freeway emissions
F𝐸𝑓𝑓iF_{\mathit{Eff}\ i} Project effectiveness factor for each affected freeway
F𝑁𝑅F_{\mathit{NR}} (percent) Nonrecurring emissions

Ramp Metering

Daily Emission Reduction (grams/day)=Aβˆ’B\text{Daily Emission Reduction (grams/day)} = A - B

A=[(VB×𝐸𝐹B)βˆ’(VA×𝐸𝐹A)]Γ—LA = [(V_{B} \times \mathit{EF}_{B}) - (V_{A} \times \mathit{EF}_{A})] \times L

The change in running exhaust emissions on the freeway along the metered section

B=NVΓ—tq×𝐸𝐹IB = N_{V} \times t_{q} \times \mathit{EF}_{I}

The increase in idling exhaust emissions from queuing at the metered ramps

Variables (Unit) Definitions
𝐸𝐹A\mathit{EF}_{A} (grams/mile) Speed-based running exhaust emission factor for mainline after implementation (NOX, VOC, PM, or CO)
𝐸𝐹B\mathit{EF}_{B} (grams/mile) Speed-based running exhaust emission factor for mainline before implementation (NOX, VOC, PM, or CO)
𝐸𝐹I\mathit{EF}_{I} (grams/hour) Idling emission factor (NOX, VOC, PM, or CO))
LL (mile) Length of freeway corridor impacted by ramp metering (in hours)
NVN_{V} Number of vehicles using metered ramps
tqt_{q} (hour) Average time spent in queue waiting to enter freeway
VAV_{A} Average traffic volume per operating period on main lanes after implementing ramp metering
VBV_{B} Average traffic volume per operating period on main lanes before implementing ramp metering

Source: Texas A&M Transportation Institute