4.0 Trip-Reduction Ordinances

Trip-reduction ordinances.
Section 108 (iv), CAAA

Introduction

Trip-reduction ordinances (TROs) consist of regulations or similar measures requiring implementation of other mobile source emission reduction strategies. TROs may specify emission reduction strategies or simply require a set reduction in VMT, trips, or other measure of reduced travel.

TROs are applied in a variety of ways, depending upon the needs of a particular locality. The focus of these ordinances has been to encourage socially beneficial travel choices rather than controlling traveler behavior. Most TROs, therefore, offer a range of travel options, but the individual traveler’s choice is voluntary. The most successful programs incorporate agencies, employees, and developers into the creation of TROs.

TROs have existed for well over a decade, with most early examples appearing in California. Due to a history of congestion and air quality problems, state legislative actions, and the interaction of CAAA requirements with the nonattainment status of its major urban areas, California remains the state with the most significant experience with TROs.

Main Components

TROs are applicable in large metropolitan areas and surrounding suburbs. Most measures are geared toward companies or developments of a minimum size. This size restriction reduces hardships on small companies and limits enforcement costs for the jurisdiction. The criterion often used for companies is the number of employees at a location. A TRO usually specifies that if a company has greater than the threshold number of employees (e.g., more than 50), it must begin complying with measures of the local TRO. In some jurisdictions, multiple thresholds exist. For example, a company with 50 employees might only have to provide preferred parking for carpools, while a company with 500 employees would be expected to provide a shuttle to the local subway station. Developers of residential, commercial, or mixed-use properties may be forced to adopt a series of measures, depending on the size of the facility. For example, a developer may need to provide vanpool parking if the office complex being built exceeds a certain size (e.g., 25,000 square feet) or if it will house more than a given number of workers.

Enforcement is another aspect of TROs that needs to be taken into consideration. Some TROs are purely voluntary, relying on the good will of businesses in achieving trip-reduction goals. In areas where compulsory TROs have been enacted, compliance is unavoidable for employers and developers. While some TROs specify no penalties, the majority of programs specify fines for given periods of noncompliance. Fines in one TRO study varied from $500 per month to $25,000 per day. In Sacramento County, California, noncompliance may be treated as a criminal misdemeanor. However, failing to fully implement TRO measures is rarely treated as a violation. This is especially true for first-time offenders or if the TRO has been recently implemented. Enforcement and punishment are usually reserved for organizations that display willful disregard toward the measure. The spirit of most TROs encourages participation rather than punishment of laggards.

Other Considerations

Some TRO measures affect only new developments/businesses. This leads to older businesses feeling no effects from a regulation, while similar organizations that are new to a community are faced with regulatory compliance efforts. Most TRO regulations, by their nature, affect businesses equally in the community. In most cases, good-faith compliance efforts by most organizations provide the important groundwork to achieve the desired environmental and social benefits, without placing undue burden on any one segment of the economy.